History
The waterfront block at St. George was used for baseball from 1853 and became part of the St. George development in 1886, when the American Association Metropolitans moved there from Manhattan. They played there in 1886 and 1887.
The New York Giants used the grounds from April 29 to June 14, 1889, after losing the original Polo Grounds, then moved to the new Polo Grounds in Manhattan. Professional baseball on the site ended with their departure.
Why it matters: A major-league home on Staten Island for the Metropolitans and, briefly, the Giants.
Then and now
Then
- Venue
- St. George Cricket Grounds, ballpark
- In use
- 1853–1889
- Sports
- Baseball
- Home team
- New York Metropolitans (1886–1887)
- Seats
- 5,100
Now
- Status
- Site redeveloped
- On the site
- Empire Outlets shopping center
- Replaced by
- Polo Grounds (1889–1890)
Compiled from the sourced facts on this page. Sources are listed below.
Timeline
The site today
| Physical status | Site redeveloped |
|---|---|
| Current use | Empire Outlets shopping center[1] |
| Mapped location | Former venue site Strongly supported: Supported by one cited source, with no conflicting source on file. |
Satellite view (external, current imagery)
Teams & events
| New York Metropolitans | AA · 1886–1887 |
|---|---|
| New York Giants | National League · 1889 · secondary |
Listed here are organizations that used this physical venue. A franchise's history and a venue's history are tracked separately.
Venue facts
| Location | Block bounded by Wall Street, the railroad and New York Bay, Hyatt Street and Jay Street (Richmond Terrace), St. George, Staten Island, New York, New York[1] Strongly supported: Supported by one cited source, with no conflicting source on file. |
|---|---|
| Venue type | Ballpark |
| Sports | Baseball |
| Level | AA, NL |
| Opened | 1853[1] Strongly supported: Supported by one cited source, with no conflicting source on file. |
| Last used for sports | 1889 Unverified: No cited source supports this value yet. |
| Physical status | Site redeveloped |
| Original capacity | 5,100[1] Strongly supported: Supported by one cited source, with no conflicting source on file. |
Connected venues
Sources
Official, government, university and archival records are marked. Encyclopedias and general reference sites are used for leads and are corroborated where we can.
- St. George Cricket GroundsEncyclopedia, Wikipedia. Accessed 2026-11-04Supports: address, capacity, coordinates, current land use, events, opened, teams
Research confidence
Some facts on this page rely on a single source or are still being corroborated. Treat specific dates and figures with care. Last reviewed 2026-10-19.
- Confirmed: Supported by two or more independent sources, with no recorded disagreement. Supported by two or more independent sources, with no recorded disagreement.
- Strongly supported: Supported by one cited source, with no conflicting source on file. Supported by one cited source, with no conflicting source on file.
- Approximate: The sources give only an approximate value (a circa date, a range, or an approximate site), or they disagree. The sources give only an approximate value (a circa date, a range, or an approximate site), or they disagree.
- Unverified: No cited source supports this value yet. No cited source supports this value yet.
See something wrong or missing? Suggest a correction or submit a source.


