History
The New York Metropolitans moved part of their 1884 American Association schedule to a riverside block in East Harlem, between 107th and 109th Streets east of First Avenue. The first game was played there on May 13, 1884.
The ground was poorly regarded and was nicknamed "The Dump" in the press. The Metropolitans returned to the Polo Grounds, playing their last game at Metropolitan Park on August 23, 1884. The site is now occupied by 1199 Plaza.
Why it matters: A short-lived alternative home of the New York Metropolitans during the 1884 season.
Then and now
Then
- Venue
- Metropolitan Park (Manhattan), ballpark
- In use
- 1884–1884
- Sports
- Baseball
- Seats
- 5,000
Now
- Status
- Site redeveloped
- On the site
- 1199 Plaza residential complex
Compiled from the sourced facts on this page. Sources are listed below.
Timeline
The site today
| Physical status | Site redeveloped |
|---|---|
| Current use | 1199 Plaza residential complex[2] |
| Mapped location | Approximate historic location Approximate: The sources give only an approximate value (a circa date, a range, or an approximate site), or they disagree. |
Teams & events
| New York Metropolitans | AA · 1884 · secondary |
|---|
Listed here are organizations that used this physical venue. A franchise's history and a venue's history are tracked separately.
Venue facts
| Other names | The Dump[2] |
|---|---|
| Location | Block bounded by East 109th Street, the Harlem River, East 107th Street and First Avenue, East Harlem, Manhattan, New York, New York[2] Approximate: The sources give only an approximate value (a circa date, a range, or an approximate site), or they disagree. |
| Venue type | Ballpark |
| Sports | Baseball |
| Level | AA |
| Opened | May 13, 1884[2] Strongly supported: Supported by one cited source, with no conflicting source on file. |
| Last used for sports | August 23, 1884[2] Strongly supported: Supported by one cited source, with no conflicting source on file. |
| Physical status | Site redeveloped |
| Original capacity | 5,000[2] Strongly supported: Supported by one cited source, with no conflicting source on file. |
| Capacity notes | About 5,000. |
| Closure | The Metropolitans returned to the Polo Grounds. |
Documented details
Sources
Official, government, university and archival records are marked. Encyclopedias and general reference sites are used for leads and are corroborated where we can.
- Polo GroundsEncyclopedia, Wikipedia. Accessed 2026-11-04Supports: teams
- Metropolitan Park (Manhattan)Encyclopedia, Wikipedia. Accessed 2026-11-04Supports: address, aliases, capacity, closed, current land use, opened, teams
- 1199 PlazaEncyclopedia, Wikipedia. Accessed 2026-11-04Supports: coordinates
Research confidence
Some facts on this page rely on a single source or are still being corroborated. Treat specific dates and figures with care. Last reviewed 2026-10-19.
- Confirmed: Supported by two or more independent sources, with no recorded disagreement. Supported by two or more independent sources, with no recorded disagreement.
- Strongly supported: Supported by one cited source, with no conflicting source on file. Supported by one cited source, with no conflicting source on file.
- Approximate: The sources give only an approximate value (a circa date, a range, or an approximate site), or they disagree. The sources give only an approximate value (a circa date, a range, or an approximate site), or they disagree.
- Unverified: No cited source supports this value yet. No cited source supports this value yet.
See something wrong or missing? Suggest a correction or submit a source.