Metropolitan Park (Manhattan)

New York, New York · Ballpark

Metropolitan Park was a short-lived 1884 home of the American Association's New York Metropolitans in East Harlem. The block is now part of the 1199 Plaza housing complex.

Opened
1884
Closed
1884
Today
Site redeveloped
Capacity
5,000

3 sources · How sure are we?

Visit the site of Metropolitan Park (Manhattan)

Some of these are affiliate links: we may earn a commission. Disclosure

Illustration, not a historical photograph.

History

The New York Metropolitans moved part of their 1884 American Association schedule to a riverside block in East Harlem, between 107th and 109th Streets east of First Avenue. The first game was played there on May 13, 1884.

The ground was poorly regarded and was nicknamed "The Dump" in the press. The Metropolitans returned to the Polo Grounds, playing their last game at Metropolitan Park on August 23, 1884. The site is now occupied by 1199 Plaza.

Why it matters: A short-lived alternative home of the New York Metropolitans during the 1884 season.

Then and now

Then

Venue
Metropolitan Park (Manhattan), ballpark
In use
1884–1884
Sports
Baseball
Seats
5,000

Now

Status
Site redeveloped
On the site
1199 Plaza residential complex

Compiled from the sourced facts on this page. Sources are listed below.

Timeline

  1. May 13, 1884
    First game[2]

    The first game at the park was played on May 13, 1884.

  2. August 23, 1884
    Last Metropolitans game[2]

    The Metropolitans played their final game here on August 23, 1884.

The site today

Physical statusSite redeveloped
Current use1199 Plaza residential complex[2]
Mapped locationApproximate historic location Approximate: The sources give only an approximate value (a circa date, a range, or an approximate site), or they disagree.

Teams & events

New York MetropolitansAA · 1884 · secondary

Listed here are organizations that used this physical venue. A franchise's history and a venue's history are tracked separately.

Venue facts

Other namesThe Dump[2]
LocationBlock bounded by East 109th Street, the Harlem River, East 107th Street and First Avenue, East Harlem, Manhattan, New York, New York[2] Approximate: The sources give only an approximate value (a circa date, a range, or an approximate site), or they disagree.
Venue typeBallpark
SportsBaseball
LevelAA
OpenedMay 13, 1884[2] Strongly supported: Supported by one cited source, with no conflicting source on file.
Last used for sportsAugust 23, 1884[2] Strongly supported: Supported by one cited source, with no conflicting source on file.
Physical statusSite redeveloped
Original capacity5,000[2] Strongly supported: Supported by one cited source, with no conflicting source on file.
Capacity notesAbout 5,000.
ClosureThe Metropolitans returned to the Polo Grounds.

Documented details

  • Players, observers and especially Brooklyn Eagle sports reporters called the park "The Dump."[2]
  • The Metropolitans returned to the Polo Grounds after a short stay.[1,2]

Sources

Official, government, university and archival records are marked. Encyclopedias and general reference sites are used for leads and are corroborated where we can.

  1. Polo GroundsEncyclopedia, Wikipedia. Accessed 2026-11-04
    Supports: teams
  2. Metropolitan Park (Manhattan)Encyclopedia, Wikipedia. Accessed 2026-11-04
    Supports: address, aliases, capacity, closed, current land use, opened, teams
  3. 1199 PlazaEncyclopedia, Wikipedia. Accessed 2026-11-04
    Supports: coordinates

Research confidence

Some facts on this page rely on a single source or are still being corroborated. Treat specific dates and figures with care. Last reviewed 2026-10-19.

  • Confirmed: Supported by two or more independent sources, with no recorded disagreement. Supported by two or more independent sources, with no recorded disagreement.
  • Strongly supported: Supported by one cited source, with no conflicting source on file. Supported by one cited source, with no conflicting source on file.
  • Approximate: The sources give only an approximate value (a circa date, a range, or an approximate site), or they disagree. The sources give only an approximate value (a circa date, a range, or an approximate site), or they disagree.
  • Unverified: No cited source supports this value yet. No cited source supports this value yet.

See something wrong or missing? Suggest a correction or submit a source.

Other venues used by the same teams

Other former venues in New York

Ridgewood Park

New York, New York · Baseball · 1885–1959

Ridgewood Park in Ridgewood, Queens, was used by Brooklyn's American Association club from 1887 to 1889 and was the 1890 home of the Brooklyn Gladiators. As Grand Stadium it hosted soccer and other sports until 1959.

Site redevelopedPartially verified

Polo Grounds (1889–1890)

New York, New York · Baseball · 1889–1890

The second Polo Grounds, at 155th Street and Eighth Avenue, was the New York Giants' home in 1889 and 1890. As Manhattan Field it was later used for football and track, and in 1948 it became a parking lot for the adjacent Polo Grounds.

Site redevelopedPartially verified

Madison Square Garden (1890)

New York, New York · Boxing & wrestling · 1890–1925

Designed by Stanford White, the second Madison Square Garden stood in Manhattan at 26th Street and Madison Avenue from 1890 to 1926. The first Millrose Games were held there, along with prizefights and six-day bicycle races.

Site redevelopedPartially verified

St. Nicholas Arena

New York, New York · Boxing & wrestling · 1896–1962

St. Nicholas Arena started out in 1896 as an ice rink on Manhattan's West 66th Street. From 1906 until its 1962 closing, it ranked among New York's leading boxing clubs. ABC later used it as a TV studio, and it was torn down in the 1980s.

Site redeveloped

Celtic Park

New York, New York · Track & field · 1898–1930

From 1898 until 1930, Celtic Park, in the Sunnyside section of Queens, was where the Irish American Athletic Club was based. That year it was sold so an apartment complex could be built.

Site redevelopedPartially verified

69th Regiment Armory

New York, New York · Basketball · 1906–c. 1999

The 69th Regiment Armory on Lexington Avenue, opened in 1906, hosted New York Knicks home games from 1946 to 1960 and the 1913 Armory Show. It remains a National Guard armory and events venue with no recorded sports use since the 1990s.

Standing, repurposedPartially verified

Nearby former venues

Closed in the same era