Lost sports venues of New York City

The atlas documents 27 former venues in New York City across its five boroughs. The oldest, St. George Cricket Grounds, opened in 1853. The most recent to close was Louis Armstrong Stadium (1978–2016), in 2016. 25 are gone or built over and 2 still stand, at least in part.

When New York City's lost venues were in use
  1. St. George Cricket Grounds1853 to 18891853–1889
  2. Union Grounds1862 to 18821862–1882
  3. Capitoline Grounds1864 to 18801864–1880
  4. Jerome Park Racetrack1866 to 18941866–1894
  5. Polo Grounds (1880–1888)1876 to 18881876–1888
  6. Metropolitan Park (Manhattan)1884 to 18841884–1884
  7. Ridgewood Park1885 to 19591885–1959
  8. Gravesend Race Track1886 to 19071886–1907
  9. Polo Grounds (1889–1890)1889 to 18901889–1890
  10. Morris Park Racecourse1889 to 19041889–1904
  11. Eastern Park1890 to 18971890–1897
  12. Madison Square Garden (1890)1890 to 19251890–1925
  13. St. Nicholas Arena1896 to 19621896–1962
  14. Celtic Park1898 to 19301898–1930
  15. Jamaica Race Course1903 to 19591903–1959
  16. 69th Regiment Armory1906 to 19991906–1999
  17. Polo Grounds1911 to 19631911–1963
  18. Ebbets Field1913 to 19571913–1957
  19. Broadway Arena1914 to 19521914–1952
  20. Thompson Stadium1920 to 19331920–1933
  21. New York Velodrome1921 to 19301921–1930
  22. Yankee Stadium1923 to 20081923–2008
  23. Madison Square Garden (1925)1925 to 19681925–1968
  24. Ridgewood Grove1926 to 19561926–1956
  25. Sunnyside Garden Arena1947 to 19771947–1977
  26. Shea Stadium1964 to 20081964–2008
  27. Louis Armstrong Stadium (1978–2016)1978 to 20161978–2016

St. George Cricket Grounds

New York, New York · Baseball · 1853–1889

The St. George Cricket Grounds on Staten Island were home to the New York Metropolitans in 1886 and 1887 and a temporary home for the Giants in 1889. The Empire Outlets shopping center now occupies the block.

Site redevelopedPartially verified

Union Grounds

Brooklyn, New York · Baseball · 1862–1882

Opened in 1862 in Williamsburg, Brooklyn, Union Grounds was the first baseball park closed in on all sides. National Association and National League teams played there in the 1870s, and it was torn down in 1883.

Site redevelopedPartially verified

Capitoline Grounds

Brooklyn, New York · Baseball · 1864–1880

Opened in 1864 in Bedford, Brooklyn, the Capitoline Grounds served as both a skating pond and a ballfield. It was here in 1870 that the Atlantics snapped Cincinnati's 84-game winning streak.

Site redeveloped

Jerome Park Racetrack

Bronx, New York · Horse racing · 1866–1894

Located in what is today the Bronx, Jerome Park was run by the American Jockey Club, and in 1867 it held the very first Belmont Stakes. It was shut down to build the Jerome Park Reservoir.

Site redevelopedPartially verified

Polo Grounds (1880–1888)

New York, New York · Baseball · c. 1876–1888

The first Polo Grounds stood just north of Central Park at 110th Street and was home to the New York Metropolitans and the New York Giants in the 1880s. It was demolished in 1889 when West 111th Street was cut through the site.

Site redevelopedPartially verified

Metropolitan Park (Manhattan)

New York, New York · Baseball · 1884–1884

Metropolitan Park was a short-lived 1884 home of the American Association's New York Metropolitans in East Harlem. The block is now part of the 1199 Plaza housing complex.

Site redevelopedPartially verified

Ridgewood Park

New York, New York · Baseball · 1885–1959

Ridgewood Park in Ridgewood, Queens, was used by Brooklyn's American Association club from 1887 to 1889 and was the 1890 home of the Brooklyn Gladiators. As Grand Stadium it hosted soccer and other sports until 1959.

Site redevelopedPartially verified

Gravesend Race Track

Brooklyn, New York · Horse racing · 1886–1907

From 1886 until New York's anti-betting laws shut down racing around 1910, the Brooklyn Jockey Club ran Thoroughbreds at Gravesend Race Track. For over ten years it was where the Preakness Stakes was held.

Site redevelopedPartially verified

Morris Park Racecourse

Bronx, New York · Horse racing · 1889–1904

From 1890 to 1904, the Belmont Stakes was run at Morris Park Racecourse in the Bronx. Once racing ended, the grounds served as an early airfield before becoming the Morris Park neighborhood.

Site redevelopedPartially verified

Polo Grounds (1889–1890)

New York, New York · Baseball · 1889–1890

The second Polo Grounds, at 155th Street and Eighth Avenue, was the New York Giants' home in 1889 and 1890. As Manhattan Field it was later used for football and track, and in 1948 it became a parking lot for the adjacent Polo Grounds.

Site redevelopedPartially verified

Eastern Park

Brooklyn (New York City), New York · Baseball · 1890–1897

Built in East New York for the Players' League in 1890, Eastern Park served as home to Brooklyn's National League team through 1897. Industry occupies the site today.

Site redevelopedPartially verified

Madison Square Garden (1890)

New York, New York · Boxing & wrestling · 1890–1925

Designed by Stanford White, the second Madison Square Garden stood in Manhattan at 26th Street and Madison Avenue from 1890 to 1926. The first Millrose Games were held there, along with prizefights and six-day bicycle races.

Site redevelopedPartially verified

St. Nicholas Arena

New York, New York · Boxing & wrestling · 1896–1962

St. Nicholas Arena started out in 1896 as an ice rink on Manhattan's West 66th Street. From 1906 until its 1962 closing, it ranked among New York's leading boxing clubs. ABC later used it as a TV studio, and it was torn down in the 1980s.

Site redeveloped

Celtic Park

New York, New York · Track & field · 1898–1930

From 1898 until 1930, Celtic Park, in the Sunnyside section of Queens, was where the Irish American Athletic Club was based. That year it was sold so an apartment complex could be built.

Site redevelopedPartially verified

Jamaica Race Course

New York (Jamaica, Queens), New York · Horse racing · 1903–1959

From 1903 to 1959, Jamaica Race Course in Queens held Thoroughbred racing and was the home of the Wood Memorial. It was knocked down in 1960, and the Rochdale Village cooperative took its place.

Site redevelopedPartially verified

69th Regiment Armory

New York, New York · Basketball · 1906–c. 1999

The 69th Regiment Armory on Lexington Avenue, opened in 1906, hosted New York Knicks home games from 1946 to 1960 and the 1913 Armory Show. It remains a National Guard armory and events venue with no recorded sports use since the 1990s.

Standing, repurposedPartially verified

Polo Grounds

New York (Manhattan), New York · Baseball · 1911–1963

Four ballparks have carried the Polo Grounds name, and this was the last. After a 1911 fire it was rebuilt on Coogan's Hollow using concrete and steel, then hosted baseball and football until 1963. It was demolished in 1964 to make room for public housing.

Site redeveloped

Ebbets Field

Brooklyn (New York City), New York · Baseball · 1913–1957

From 1913 through 1957, the Brooklyn Dodgers played at Ebbets Field in Flatbush. The ballpark was torn down in 1960, and an apartment complex took its place.

Site redeveloped

Broadway Arena

New York, New York · Boxing & wrestling · 1914–1952

Brooklyn's Broadway Arena, on Halsey Street, ran boxing from 1914 to 1951, with wrestling lasting until 1952. Afterward the building served as a warehouse and then a supermarket, and housing stands there today.

Site redevelopedPartially verified

Thompson Stadium

Staten Island (New York City), New York · Football · c. 1920–1933

From 1929 through 1932, Thompson Stadium, a modest ballpark in Stapleton, Staten Island, was where the Staten Island Stapletons of the NFL played. Demolished in 1958, it gave way to the Stapleton Houses, which stand there today.

Site redevelopedPartially verified

New York Velodrome

New York, New York · Cycling · 1921–1930

Pro bicycle races were staged at the New York Velodrome, located on 225th Street in the Bronx, from 1921 until fire destroyed it on August 4, 1930. The River Plaza shopping center now covers part of the land.

Site redevelopedPartially verified

Yankee Stadium

New York (Bronx), New York · Baseball · 1923–2008

From 1923 to 2008 the original Yankee Stadium stood in the Bronx, on the corner of 161st Street and River Avenue. The Yankees played there for most of those years, and its replacement went up on the other side of the street.

Site redeveloped

Madison Square Garden (1925)

New York, New York · Boxing & wrestling · 1925–1968

From 1925 to 1968 the third Madison Square Garden occupied the block of Eighth Avenue from 49th to 50th Streets, hosting the Knicks, the Rangers and New York's largest fights. Once the Garden relocated to Penn Station the building was demolished, and Worldwide Plaza now sits there.

Site redeveloped

Ridgewood Grove

Ridgewood (Queens, New York City), New York · Boxing & wrestling · 1926–1956

On the Brooklyn-Queens border, Ridgewood Grove staged boxing and wrestling in a 4,000-seat arena between 1926 and 1956, with a short comeback in the 1980s. The building still stands with new uses.

Standing, repurposedPartially verified

Sunnyside Garden Arena

Sunnyside (Queens, New York City), New York · Boxing & wrestling · 1947–1977

Sunnyside Garden Arena, a small boxing and wrestling club in Queens, ran from the late 1940s until 1977 in a building the Gould family had once used for tennis. It was demolished in 1977 and replaced by a fast-food restaurant.

Site redeveloped

Shea Stadium

Queens, New York · Baseball · 1964–2008

Located in Flushing Meadows, Shea Stadium was home to the Mets from 1964 through 2008 and to the Jets through 1983. It was taken apart in 2008-09, and the ground it sat on is now Citi Field parking.

Demolished

Louis Armstrong Stadium (1978–2016)

New York (Flushing, Queens), New York · Tennis · 1978–2016

Converted from the Singer Bowl built for the 1964 World's Fair, this version of Louis Armstrong Stadium was the US Open's main court from 1978 through 1996, then served as its second court until 2016.

Site redeveloped

All lost venues in New York →