History
Brotherhood Park was built for the 1890 Players' League season, the league's only year. The 1892 city directory places it at Willson Avenue and the Nickel Plate tracks, with a short right field beside the railroad.
Unlike most Players' League parks, the Cleveland grounds kept the Brotherhood name after the league folded and were used for local sports until developers bought the land in the mid-1890s.
Why it matters: Cleveland's Players' League ballpark.
Then and now
Then
- Venue
- Brotherhood Park (Cleveland), ballpark
- In use
- 1890–1890
- Sports
- Baseball
- Home team
- Cleveland Infants (1890)
Now
- Status
- Demolished
- On the site
- Not yet verified
Compiled from the sourced facts on this page. Sources are listed below.
The site today
| Physical status | Demolished |
|---|---|
| Mapped location | Approximate historic location Approximate: The sources give only an approximate value (a circa date, a range, or an approximate site), or they disagree. |
We have not verified what occupies the site today. Know? Tell us, with a source.
Teams & events
| Cleveland Infants | Players' League · 1890 |
|---|
Listed here are organizations that used this physical venue. A franchise's history and a venue's history are tracked separately.
Venue facts
| Other names | Players League Park (Cleveland) |
|---|---|
| Location | Willson Avenue (now East 55th Street) at the Nickel Plate Railroad, Cleveland, Ohio[1] Approximate: The sources give only an approximate value (a circa date, a range, or an approximate site), or they disagree. |
| Venue type | Ballpark |
| Sports | Baseball |
| Level | Players' League |
| Opened | 1890[2] Strongly supported: Supported by one cited source, with no conflicting source on file. |
| Last used for sports | 1890[2] Strongly supported: Supported by one cited source, with no conflicting source on file. |
| Physical status | Demolished |
| Surface | Grass |
| Closure | The Players' League folded after 1890; developers later bought the land. |
Documented details
- The park hosted local sports and other events until developers bought it in the mid-1890s.[1]
Sources
Official, government, university and archival records are marked. Encyclopedias and general reference sites are used for leads and are corroborated where we can.
- Brotherhood ParkEncyclopedia, Wikipedia. Accessed 2026-11-04Supports: address, coordinates, facts, teams
- Brotherhood Park, Cleveland (CLE04)Reference, Baseball Data Hub. Accessed 2026-11-04Supports: closed, coordinates, opened, teams
Research confidence
Key facts on this page (opening, closing, status and location) are each supported by sources, with key dates corroborated by at least two independent sources. Last reviewed 2026-10-19.
- Confirmed: Supported by two or more independent sources, with no recorded disagreement. Supported by two or more independent sources, with no recorded disagreement.
- Strongly supported: Supported by one cited source, with no conflicting source on file. Supported by one cited source, with no conflicting source on file.
- Approximate: The sources give only an approximate value (a circa date, a range, or an approximate site), or they disagree. The sources give only an approximate value (a circa date, a range, or an approximate site), or they disagree.
- Unverified: No cited source supports this value yet. No cited source supports this value yet.
Where sources disagree (1)
- Contemporary reports disagree on whether the park was by the Nickel Plate tracks or near Woodland Avenue about half a mile north.
See something wrong or missing? Suggest a correction or submit a source.